THE CONFIGURATION OF THE NEW DAMAGE CONCEPTION BY THE THEORY OF LOST OPPORTUNITY

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.12597056

Keywords:

Reparação civil. Dano. Indenização. Tutela de direitos e garantias individuais. Perda de chances.

Abstract

The theme of this paper is the responsibility incidence on the theory of the loss of a chance through a new conception of damage characterized by emerging damage (what the victim actually lost) and loss of profit (which effectively failed to win). Involving them in the question of the likelihood of future outcome by the chances and opportunities lost in analysing how the facts unfolded. The following problem was investigated: "How is the new conception of damage configured in the theory of the loss of a chance?" The following hypothesis was considered: "The new conception of damage in the theory of the loss of a chance is formed from the discussion between emerging gains and lost profits through the loss of potential or imminent opportunities." The overall goal is to "Analyse the new conception of damage configured in the theory of the loss of a chance". The specific objectives are: "To characterize the relevant losses of chances and opportunities with illicit act and / or property damage; "Demonstrate the broad areas of law that can be appreciated by the theory of the loss of a chance"; "Select classic jurisprudential cases under the perception of applicability of the theory of the loss of a chance"; "Appreciate civil redress for lost chances in Brazilian courts." This work is important from an individual perspective because of the importance that the applicability of the theory of the loss of a chance has in Brazilian law, despite the strong resistance to the innovations brought under the law. A new conception of damage that permeates emerging damages and lost profits enables a better understanding of extensible, difficult-to-prove damages and that their claims can be safeguarded as fairly and broadly as possible. For science it is relevant because it demonstrates the need for knowledge of the various situations covered by the theory of loss the of a chance, as well as the branches of the law reached by it. It is important to know how doctrine and jurisprudence deal with the subject, being something recent and innovative, often unknown, but if applied seriously and correctly, with all the requirements fulfilled can be very successful among Brazilian lawyers; It adds to the society because it encompasses situations in which the individual is prevented from gaining an advantage or avoiding harm due to the illicit act of a third party. Basically, the loss of a chance is the frustration of a desired opportunity if it had not been interrupted by someone else's harmful act. Thus, generating the right to compensation. Thus, the chance must be real and serious and the compensation proportional with the victim's chance of success at the time of the fact. This is a theoretical qualitative research lasting six months.

 

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Rafaella Nunes Augusto Gomes, Faculdade Processus -DF, Brasil

Graduanda em Direito pela Faculdade Processus-DF, Brasil.

CV: http://lattes.cnpq.br/6571244248387195.

Orcid: http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3122-3824.

E-mail: [email protected]

Jonas Rodrigo Gonçalves, Faculdade Processus -DF, Brasil

Doutorando em Psicologia; Mestre em Ciência Política (Direitos Humanos e Políticas Públicas); Licenciado em Filosofia e Letras (Português e Inglês); Especialista em Direito Constitucional e Processo Constitucional, em Direito Administrativo, em Direito do Trabalho e Processo Trabalhista, entre outras especializações. Professor das faculdades Processus (DF), Unip (SP), Facesa (GO), CNA (DF). Escritor (autor de 61 livros didáticos/acadêmicos). Revisor. Editor. CV Lattes: http://lattes.cnpq.br/6904924103696696. ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4106-8071. E-mail: [email protected].

References

AMARAL, Ana Cláudia Corrêa Zuin Mattos; PONA, Everton Willian. A perda da chance na jurisprudência do Superior Tribunal de Justiça – os (des)caminhos de uma compreensão teórica. SCIENTIA IURIS. 2014, Vol. 18 n. 2

CARNAÚBA, Daniel Amaral. A responsabilidade civil pela perda de uma chance: a técnica na jurisprudência francesa. Revista dos tribunais online: Thomson Reuters. 2012, Vol. 922, n. 450363

COSTA, Caroline Amorim; A responsabilidade civil e a teoria da perda de uma chance – Perte d"™una chance. Direito Izabela Hendrix. 2012, Vol. 9, n.9

JÚNIOR, José Albenes Bezerra; AZEVEDO, Walter de Medeiros; Teoria da perda de uma chance na ótica do direito brasileiro. Revista Científica da escola de direito. 2011-2012, n. 1

MARINOTO, Denise Nunes. CASALI, Éllen Cássia Giacomini; Aplicabilidade da teoria da perda de uma chance na responsabilidade civil. REVISTA LINHAS JURíDICAS (UNIFEV). 2012, Vol. 4, n. 4

NASCIMENTO, Alexandre dos Santos; NETTO; Roberto Magno Reis; Teoria da perda de uma chance: uma análise dos argumentos jurisprudenciais favoráveis í  sua aceitação no Brasil. Revista Capital Científico – Eletrônica (RCCe). 2018, Vol. 16, n. 4.

ROSíRIO, Grácia Cristina Moreira; A Perda da Chance de Cura na Responsabilidade Médica. Revista da EMERJ. 2008, Vol.11, n 43.

SILVA, Clóvis Verí­ssimo do Couto. O conceito de dano no direito brasileiro e comparado. Revista dos tribunais online: Thomson Reuters. 2015, Vol. 2, n. 2169

TORRES, Felipe Soares; O dano decorrente da perda de uma chance: questões problemáticas. Revista dos Tribunais. 2015, Vol. 958.

Published

2020-07-01

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 3 > >>